Want To Avoid Unnecessary Tests? Stick To One ER, Researchers Say – Kaiser Health News

On a recent Friday night at the Boston Children’s Hospital ER, Dr. Fabienne Bourgeois was having difficulty treating a 17-year-old boy with a heart problem. The teen had transferred in  from another hospital, where he had already had an initial work-up – including a chest X-ray and an EKG to check the heart’s electrical activity. But by the time he reached pediatrician Bourgeois, she had no access to those records so she gave him another EKG and chest X-ray. He was on multiple medications, and gave her a list of them. But his list differed from the one his mother gave doctors, neither of which matched the list his previous hospital had sent along.

via Want To Avoid Unnecessary Tests? Stick To One ER, Researchers Say – Kaiser Health News.

This is excellent advice.

Every ED has seen a patient, probably today, with “they saw me at the ER across town, but they didn’t do anything and I’m still sick”.  While it makes some sense not to return to a restaurant that gave you a meal that wasn’t to your tastes, medicine is quite different.

If a patient gives me this history, I now have a blank slate, and need to essentially start at zero with them.  So, I will do the correct workup to exclude the life threats based on the history and physical exam, which may be exactly the tests they had yesterday.  I’m not going to assume they did the same tests, or that they were normal.  It’s the standard of care at this time, and I have very very few alternatives.

Let’s flip this around: it’s a patient we saw a day or three ago who comes back to us and says “I’m not better”, that’s so much better for the patient, and us!  We have immediate access to their records and tests, and will not have to repeat studies we already know the result of.  Therefore, the patient avoids unnecessary testing, and gets better care.

Yes, you say, you could get the records from the other hospital, and the answer is, maybe, someday, better during M-F business hours (when hospitals are set up to work, still), less on Sunday AM on a 4 day weekend.  Someday EMR’s will be inter-operational, but frankly that’s going to require legislation as hospital systems want to own ‘covered lives’ and they see contro of medical records as proprietary information as theirs and theirs alone.  (Also, who’s going to spend money to give away their information)?

So, stick to one ED.  Yeah, sometimes you have to go back a couple of times.  That’s okay.  It’s the right thing for you.


  1. This should be published for the public and a major emphasis in EMS training courses! A patient can be transferred if a higher level of care is necessary — only in a truly emergent situation should a patient come to a hospital where he has no history.

  2. Don’t forget the medicaid patients who “shop for tests” by going to another hospital when they didn’t get their early pregnancy ultrasound done in the ER at 2AM. They tweak their story, or claim “that other place didn’t do nothin'”

    Yeah… plenty of money gets wasted on stuff like that, along with the drug-seekers and doctor-shoppers.

    Oh… and the homeless patients who come in complaining of chest pain… or of getting hit by a car… when all they want is something to eat, and a warm place to sleep… and they’re too drunk to stay at the shelter…

  3. I love it when they come in without records and say “Don’t you guys talk to one another?” as if we were all standing around the water cooler sharing their EMR. Someday…..


  1. […] the complete story @  GruntDoc. Filed Under: Health Care Tagged With: Better Patient Care, ED, Electronic Medical Records, […]